So, Now what? The player on that board had some grievances and quoted the other players as having some to. Now, I don't know which of you has it right, and if that even matters. But I do think you need to get on the same page before starting play again.
I think this group is doomed.Wow, that's me and my party. Like, that is literally a post by one of my players describing the game thus far..
I'd say, just let them play whatever they want. They seem to be novices as far as I can tell. So the superiority of casters might not be a huge problem. Also, when starting at lvl 1, the fighter is far from underpowered. Even with only toughness and weapon focus.
Actually turned out te be a pretty decent discussion over there. Aside from the obvious asshats. Did you read?
I definitely read the thread, and I agree that it was valuable insight to what I look like from the outside no matter my personal excuses.
I'm hoping I can get everyone in the group on the same page. Most likely, I will have to reel back some of the intense roleplay I like in order to introduce some combat to get everyone used to the mechanics. Then, if they choose to go into deeper roleplay they can.
I probably need to start a bit more vanilla, so to say.
It will be difficult to get the person who gets his thrills from landing a mighty blow and the person who gets her thrills from character development to come to a more moderate compromise.